Two things in the past few days – my own experience with the AI assistant Claude and a Microsoft server outage that made headlines around the world – have raised the same question: Are we becoming too dependent on the cloud?

The cloud is convenient

If your PC breaks down, you don’t lose the data you’ve already stored in the cloud. You can retrieve it from another device.

It’s useful even when nothing breaks: you can access your collection on your PC, tablet and smartphone without having to copy it manually each time. Services with automatic backups also save you the trouble of making regular copies yourself. Keeping a copy no longer depends on you remembering to make one.

The provider benefits too: once you’ve spent years accumulating data with a service and know your way around it, you’re reluctant to switch. You wouldn’t just have to get set up with a new service; you’d also have to transfer your existing collection in a usable form. That lock-in is part of the business model.

A service like this resembles a walled garden: much of what’s inside is well tended and inviting. You know your way around and are happy to stay. You often don’t look for the gate until you want to leave. Day-to-day life inside tells you little about how well the gate works.

An export isn’t the same as a readable archive

I exported my chats with Claude because I was worried they might disappear one day. You request the export in the settings, and the download link arrives by email. I received all my chats – but in a file meant for programmers. I had to write a small program before I could read them.

That format can be useful for processing the data with software. But it still isn’t a readable archive. If you want to look up a conversation later, you need a program that presents the content clearly – not the skills to write one.

What gets left behind when you transfer photos

There’s more to a photo collection than you see at first glance. Google offers a way to transfer a copy of your photos and videos directly to other services. Switching is supported. The question is which parts of your existing collection make it to the new service.

Google itself lists what doesn’t transfer, including comments added to photos later, the video component of Live Photos and unsaved Memories in Google Photos.

A comment you’ve added can be just as important to preserving a memory as the photo itself. So seeing a photo in the new service doesn’t prove that the collection has been transferred in full. The exit is there, but not everything fits through the gate.

When the service is down for a day

With the Microsoft outage, the issue wasn’t leaving the service but accessing it: people who only read their email in a browser couldn’t see any of it for hours. An email program on your PC that has downloaded your messages in full can still display them when the service is unavailable – regardless of the provider.

You can also keep working during a server outage: emails you write simply wait in the outbox until the server is back online.

The exit test

The exit shows whether the cloud is serving you or keeping you dependent: can you get your data out, is it complete and can you open it in a program from a different provider? If the exit exists only on paper, you’re keeping too much in the cloud.

Try exporting your data before you need to and while you can still access your account. Start with the service that holds your most important data.

Request the export when you have time. Some download links expire after a day. With Claude, the link may work only once. So save the file to your computer promptly. Keeping the email with the link is no substitute for downloading the file.

Check that everything is there. Compare the export with your content on the service. Make a point of checking both older and newer content, not just the first file. Also check things you added later, such as comments, and any related files. The number of downloaded files alone tells you little about whether your archive is complete.

Open the content in a different program. On your PC, use a program from a different provider. Check whether you can actually read or view the content and find a specific item again. A double-click that just takes you back to the original service’s website isn’t enough.

Keep a readable copy of what matters most. Save it somewhere that isn’t being synced with the cloud, such as on an external hard drive that you then unplug. The easiest way to tell whether you really have the content locally is to try disconnecting from the internet.

The cloud is useful for many things, as long as the exit is open.

Have you ever tried to get your photos, emails or chats back out of the cloud – and how did it go?

Comments

1
Marc Verhamme
4 hours ago
Goed artikel.
Like Like like 1 Reply
1
Wayne
3 hours ago
I have a Linux-based server here where my photos are stored. It is backed up every day by two other devices. Sure there is a possibility my house could burn down (in which case the cloud serves as an offsite backup), but my reliance on the cloud would only be secondary or tertiary at best.
There is a story some years back where a well-known camera manufacturer offered cloud storage to consumers. When its cloud completely and utterly failed, all that was left were low-resolution thumbnails. Many consumers lost their cherished photos they saved over the years. And this doesn't even speak to cloud reliability in these days of cybersecurity issues.
If you want to be sure your photos and other crucial documents are safe, there are plenty of off-line USB-based storage devices to back up your photos. Important point: do not leave them connected to your computer 24/7. If you should acquire a virus, disconnected offline storage will not be infected.
Like Like like 2 Reply
0
Joop V
2 hours ago
This is the way I do it as well. Main storage is on a Linux server at home, backup is to Proton drive and every now and then I backup by using an USB drive
Like Like like 1 Reply
0
David Cohen
2 hours ago
I even backup OneDrive - full and differentials - Using WinZip jobs. Works well. I also download all my Google photos and take backups of Keep, Calendar, Contacts (Android phone export). I already have client based email (Outlook) as that gives me some protection against Cloud outages. This all takes time and effort (depends on apps etc.), whioch most people might not be willing to do.
Like Like like 1 Reply
0
Carl J
1 hour ago
My solution.
4 disk Array using StableBit, each drive in the pool is readable separately, 2 copies of each file. Second 4 disk Array, copy of the first, 1 copy of each file. Large USB external drive, third copy. Four copies locally. Final copy to kDrive, offsite copy. FreeFileSync is the app I use for copying data between storage devices.

Periodic dump of credentials (export passwords from browser)
Macrium Reflect (free version) image of the system OS/data/apps, done quarterly. Recovers the PC if it dies.

Everyone else in the house, their device is synced to kDrive as their data preservation solution.

Takes time but I have lost digital pictures in the past, but since recovered when the main array had issues.
Like Like Reply
0
Tess
43 minutes ago
This household doesn't use the cloud for anything. Two phone backups are done weekly to the computers and the computers are done weekly to a roomy USB drive. The drive is stored in a safe place and is number one on the list of items to grab-n-go if a fire breaks out. Even if I can't get to my laptop (which is number two on the list because it's the one that manages the household), I can replace the programs on it and the particulars with the USB backups. The whole shenanigan fits in my purse. It's bad enough that everybody we do business with online backs up their crap to the cloud, with your crap in it. And they wonder why there are breaches every five minutes.
Like Like Reply

Add comment

Submit